“Church discipline is the church’s exercise of authority given by Christ.” (Book of Order, D-1.0101)

The Permanent Judicial Commission (PJC) of the Synod of the Northeast receives remedial complaints that are filed concerning a presbytery or appeals from presbytery PJC decisions. They determine whether to approve or decline requests for stays of enforcement and hold pre-trial conferences, trials and appeal hearings. Members serve on the PJC for one term of six years.

View PJC decisions and access the resource directory. »

 

Current members of the Permanent Judicial Commission

TE Katy Stenta, Albany
RE Jim McKinsey, Boston
TE Shelley Gardner, Elizabeth
RE Catherine Forester, Genesee Valley
RE Carol Dornbush, Hudson River
TE Jin Oh Bae, Newark

RE Joe Martinoni, Newton
RE Brunhilda Sanders-Lane, New York City
TE Blair Moffett, Northern New England
TE Casey Carbone, Northern New York
RE Daniel Ramirez, Palisades
TE Cass Shaw, Southern New England

Resources

The following resources may be helpful for anyone who has business before the Permanent Judicial Commission of the Synod of the Northeast, a synod of the Presbyterian Church (USA).
    Communicating with the PJC  (downloadable version coming soon)
    Presbyterian Church (USA)
    Book of Order  (see second item in list)
    Annotated Book of Order  (see third item in list)
    Online version of the Annotated Book of Order  (under "Constitution of the PC(USA)" in menu)
    General Assembly Permanent Judicial Commission (GA PJC)
    GA PJC Decisions
    Office of the General Assembly (OGA) Advisory Opinions
    OGA Constitutional Musings
    GA PJC Resources Page

Resources

The following resources may be helpful for anyone who has business before the Permanent Judicial Commission of the Synod of the Northeast, a synod of the Presbyterian Church (USA).

    Communicating with the PJC  (downloadable version coming soon)
    Presbyterian Church (USA)
    Book of Order  (see second item in list)
    Annotated Book of Order  (see third item in list)
    Online version of the Annotated Book of Order  (under "Constitution of the PC(USA)" in menu)
    General Assembly Permanent Judicial Commission (GA PJC)
    GA PJC Decisions
    Office of the General Assembly (OGA) Advisory Opinions
    OGA Constitutional Musings
    GA PJC Resources Page


Communicating with the Synod PJC

If you need to file anything with the Synod PJC, it is important to follow these instructions:

Document Formats

All documents submitted to, and sent by, the PJC shall be submitted in PDF format and, where applicable, shall be electronically signed. These documents shall be original electronic documents, not scanned versions of paper copies, unless an electronic version of the document cannot be obtained with a reasonable amount of effort. If a signature is required on a document and electronic signing is not available, the original electronic (unsigned) document may be accompanied by a scanned version of the signed paper document.

Means of Delivery

All documents shall be delivered via email or made available through secure websites, such as FTP, Google Drive, Dropbox, etc., their location to be specified through email messages. Paper copies of documents are sent through regular USPS mail, but not through certified mail, except where required by the Rules of Discipline (filing of complaints and appeals, decisions).* The sending of paper documents through certified mail (or equivalent service) in those cases does not replace the requirement to transmit the electronic copies.

Channels of Communication

Each party in cases before, or coming before, the PJC shall provide the Office of the Stated Clerk with at least one, but no more than three, email addresses for all communication with the party.
All correspondence to the PJC shall be directed to the Office of the Stated Clerk, with copies to the parties in the case at all times. The Office of the Stated Clerk shall forward all correspondence and documents directed to the PJC to the PJC Executive Committee within two business days. Correspondence from the PJC shall be sent by the Office of the Stated Clerk with BCC to the Executive Committee.

* D-6.0301, D-7.0402c, D-8.0202f, D-8.0404c, D-11.0403g, D-13.0202f, D-13.0404e

For a downloadable version of these communication rules click here (coming soon).


Synod PJC Cases

These are the cases that have become before the Permanent Judicial Commission (PJC) of the Synod of the Northeast of the Presbyterian Church (USA) since 2009.

The encoded types of cases are:
R: Remedial
D: Disciplinary
AR: Appeal of a remedial case
AD: Appeal of a disciplinary case
Ref: Request for Reference
PTC: Pretrial Conference

Scroll table to see case number, title, type, date of decision, decision, and any appeal to the General Assembly PJC. Links to decisions and appeals are coming soon.

CASE TITLE TYPE DATE OF DECISION DECISION APPEAL TO GA PJC
SNE 2018-02 Patricia F. Wolff v. Presbytery of Susquehanna Valley R 2018-11-27 Provisionally dismissed
SNE 2018-01 China-Richardson & Nguidgol v. AC at Elmwood United Presbyterian Church R 2018-04-05 - Appealed to GAPJC Failed Preliminary Questions
SNE 2017-06 PC(USA) v. Aquino, Campbell, Duho, Fingal, Jan, Lunga, Taylor D 2018-04-11 - Appealed to GAPJC Decision & Order
SNE 2017-05 Richard Hong, Rev. Samuel Weddington v. Presbytery of the Palisades R 2017-12-01 Failed Preliminary Questions
SNE 2017-04 Session of the Pilgrim Church of New Jersey v. Eastern Korean Presbytery AR 2017-11-29 Failed Preliminary Questions
SNE 2017-03 Session of Pilgrim Church of New Jersey v. Eastern Korean Presbytery R 2017-07-20 Failed Preliminary Questions
SNE 2017-02 Jean Risley v. Presbytery of Boston R 2017-03-26 Failed Preliminary Questions
SNE 2017-01 Session of Pilgrim Church of New Jersey, et al., v. Eastern Korean Presbytery R 2017-04-25 - Appealed to GAPJC Failed Preliminary Questions
SNE 2015-02 Session of Pilgrim Church of New Jersey v. Eastern Korean Presbytery R 2016-01-12 Withdrawn Withdrawn and terminated
SNE 2015-01 Allen Shelton v. Presbytery of Newark R 2015-08-13 Failed Preliminary Questions
SNE 2014-05 Wilson-Bridges v. Presbytery of New York City R 2015-03-03 (PTC)  2015-05-19 (Decision) Dismissed
SNE 2014-04 Sylvia Kuzmak v. Session First Presbyterian Church at Red Bank, NJ AR 2015-05-19 Appeal not sustained - PPJC decision upheld GAPJC 222-07 - SPJC Decision Upheld
SNE 2014-03 Jamelle Straker v. Newark Presbytery R 2014-06-23 Failed Preliminary Questions
SNE 2014-02 Presbytery of New Brunswick v. TE Elizabeth Vandegrift D 2014-10-16 (PTC) 2014-11-17 (Decision) Dismissed
SNE 2014-01 PJC Presbytery of New York City Ref 2014-01-23 Request for reference rejected
SNE 2013-06 Seung Joon Lee v. Eastern Korean Presbytery R Consolidated with - SNE 2013-01
SNE 2013-05 Session Park Presbyterian Church v. Presbytery of Geneva R 2014-05-09 Decision & Order
SNE 2013-04 Mark Davis v. Session First Presbyterian Church at Red Bank, NJ AR 2014-05-07 Appeal not sustained - PPJC decision upheld
SNE 2013-03 McGee et al. v. Presbytery of New York City R 2013-09-11 Decision & Order GAPJC 221-08 - SPJC Decision Upheld
SNE 2013-02 Seung Joon Lee v. Eastern Korean Presbytery R 2013-06-11 Decision & Order
SNE 2013-01 Seung Joon Lee v. Eastern Korean Presbytery R 2014-01-23 Decision & Order
SNE 2012-02 David Hamilton v. Session of Middletown United Presbyterian Church AR 2012-09-13 Appeal sustained - PPJC decision to dismiss reversed
SNE 2012-01 Patricia B. Fish v. the Presbytery of Newark R 2012-12-10 Decision & Order
SNE 2011-03 Sheldon, Myers v. Presbytery of West Jersey R 2011-06-20 Decision & Order
SNE 2011-01 Presbytery of Newark v. McNeill AD 2011-12-09 Appeal dismissed - PPJC decision upheld GAPJC 221-02 - SPJC decision upheld
SNE 2010-04 Vandegrift v. Presbytery of New Brunswick R 2011-06-21 Decision & Order
SNE 2010-03 Edmonds v. Presbytery of NYC R 2011-04-01 Decision & Order GAPJC 220-09 - SPJC decision reversed, case dismissed
SNE 2010-02 Karimiv v. Presbytery of NNE AD 2011-03-31 Dismissed
SNE 2010-01 Chambers v. Presbytery of NYC R 2011-09-19 Decision & Order
SNE 2009-07 Winter & Short v. Presbytery of Cayuga-Syracuse R 2010-12-09 Withdrawn and dismissed
SNE 2009-06 Einhorn v. Presbytery of Monmouth AR 2010-04-28 Appeal dismissed - PPJC decision upheld
SNE 2009-05 Presbytery of Boston v. Southard AD 2010-06-25 Appeal sustained - PPJC decision reversed GAPJC 220-02 - SPJC decision reversed in part
SNE 2009-04 Grace v. Presbytery of Palisades R 2010-04-27 Decision & Order

Permanent Judicial Commission

For questions about the Synod Permanent Judicial Commission (PJC),
email our Synod Stated Clerk, Rev. Nancy Talbot.